By Andrea Leccese
July 2nd, 2021
Investors always prefer financial assets with high liquidity and reflective of the real trading conditions, with no wash trading or market manipulation. However, sometimes the public data may not be trustful, like in the case of crypto markets. In this research article, we analyzed historical volume data of a highly popular cryptocurrency exchange and evaluated to what extent the reported volume reflects the real one.
Cryptocurrency Trading Volume Reported by the Exchange
In our previous article 3 Major Benefits of Crypto Liquidity Provision on Price, Volume and Volatility, we analyzed the market liquidity from three different aspects and how investors could benefit from high liquid market. Similarly, exchanges with high liquidity would be more appealing to investors, which enable them to charge more for listing fees. That’s why some cryptocurrency platforms or tokens inflated their trading volumes. In this report, we analyzed the trading volume reported by an exchange.
Figure 1 shows the reported trading volume of trading pairs listed on an exchange platform. After log transformation, the distribution of trading volume is close to a normal distribution, with a peak at 10, which is around $30,000. Figure 2 shows the distribution of spread, which is concentrated at the range -320% to -160%. Those are the data reported by exchanges. Table 1 summarizes some basic statistics of spread and the reported trading volumes of trading pairs we analyzed in this report. The average spread is 0.75% with a standard deviation of 3.89%. The small spread indicates high liquidity of the market and low trading costs. Unlike spread, trading volume is more spread, with volume from 0.63 to 2.2 billion. However, if we only use spread and trading volume as criterion of liquid markets, we would probably pick the wrong markets.
Real Crypto Trading Volume after Removing Wash Trading
In the previous section we mentioned why some exchanges or tokens have incentives to fake their trading volume. In this section, we will analyze the truth under the veil. Before dive into the analysis, we need to understand how traders manipulate the trading volume through wash trading. Wash trading refers to a practice in which an investor places sell and buy orders on the same asset simultaneously in order to generate misleading information of a market such as a high liquidity or a high demand of the asset.
Figure 3 shows the distribution of real trading volume, which is completely different from the distribution of the reported trading volume showed in Figure 1. While the reported trading volume concentrated at range 8 to 13, the real trading volume peaked at range 0 to 1. Figure 4 shows the percentage of real trading volume in the reported trading volume. For most cases, only up to 5% of the trading volume reported is based on real trades.
Table 2 shows the statistics of real trading volume and the reported trading volume. The huge difference between those two volumes could also be detected from their statistics. For example, the averages of the real and the reported trading volume are not even at the same magnitude.
Such difference also exists while analyzing trading pairs based on trading type. Figure 5 shows the spread vs. trading volume for different types of trades. Again, we could see that the real trading volume (in blue) has a smaller intercept than the intercept of the reported trading volume line (in red), indicating that real trading volume is much smaller than the trading volume reported by exchange platforms. Moreover, the real trading volume tends to be more sensitive to the spread than the total volume does, with a higher absolute value of slope.
Table 3 shows the regression models of regressing spread on the real and the reported trading volumes. Except for spot, the regression models based on the real trading volume data have better performances than models based on the reported trading volume, with higher R square. For spot, the small sample size could be a reason for the R square being slightly lower than that of the model using the reported trading volume data. As the reported trading volume includes plenty of fake trades, we would expect a weak relationship between spread and the reported trading volume and that’s what the results we got as well.
The previous results highlight the following key insights:
- Only around 5% of trading volume reported on the analyzed cryptocurrency exchange is real trading volume, while 95% constitutes wash trading: in order to attract more investors, exchanges may pump the trading volume on their platform. Based on our samples, the average value of trading volume is around $5,612,502.82, while the average of the reported trading volume reported is $11,404,413.29. The real trading volume has a completely different distribution with the trading volume reported.
- Regression models based on the real trading volume have better performance than those based on the reported volume: as the reported trading volume includes a substantial amount of fake trades, it cannot provide an accurate picture of the market liquidity. However, the real trading volume data is more useful in market analysis, providing models with higher explanatory power.
- More regulation and accountability is needed in the crypto market: it’s very easy from this article there are many proponents in the crypto market advocating for less regulation. It provides them with an environment with no accountability where they can deceive market participants to attract clients for their business. According to the pervasiveness of wash trading and market manipulation present in crypto, more regulation is needed to instill trust in the market and attract more institutional capital.
- Token projects and investors should partner with a trusted advisor to help them navigate the crypto market: token firms looking to launch their token or investors seeking to enter the space should partner with a trusted advisor like our firm that has a long experience in the crypto space and can help them avoid potential losses by going with the wrong exchanges.
Subscribe to our newsletter to receive our latest insights in quantitative investment management. For more info about our investment products, send us an email at email@example.com or fill out our info request form.